Suttons Bay

The attractive area of Suttons Bay is the gateway to Leelanau County because it’s a couple of minutes away from the great Traverse City. A few minutes from Northport and Leland and roughly thirty minutes from Glen Arbor make Suttons Bay a conveniently central point. This laid-back yet busy town flaunts being an all-year-round coastal region with vibrant businesses.

This page gives a very detailed overview of the homes, condominiums, land, and commercial property for sale in Suttons Bay, Michigan.

Real Estate Statistics

Average Price $458K
Lowest Price $51.9K
Highest Price $3.9M
Total Listings 46
Avg. Days On Market 330
Avg. Price/SQFT $339

Property Types (active listings)


Browse Suttons Bay Homes for Sale

Click the links below to sort results by price range.

Check out this video for a look at the Suttons Bay community, or click here to learn more about Suttons Bay Homes for Sale

Suttons Bay Homes for Sale

Buying a home at Suttons Bay, MI, is a dream for most people. However, it is one of the most significant financial decisions that often seem overwhelming.

If you do thorough research and take your time, you can surely get your dream home. Whether you are in the market for a new home or preparing to buy one, it’s essential to know what to expect when searching for homes for sale in Suttons Bay.

Remember that finding a perfect home is almost impossible, so you need to think about your wants. It’s sensible to start by recognizing what you want and the things you can easily relinquish. For instance, having a big family may necessitate you to buy a home with a couple of bedrooms, but you can sacrifice other things such as a beautiful view and a great yard.

Simply put, having an idea of the things you want can help you avoid buying a lovely home that doesn’t meet your budget and requirements. Read on to discover what Suttons Bay homes have in store for you.

Welcome to Suttons Bay

The attractive area of Suttons Bay is the gateway to Leelanau County because it’s a couple of minutes away from the great Traverse City.

A few minutes from Northport and Leland and roughly thirty minutes from Glen Arbor make Suttons Bay a conveniently central point. This laid-back yet busy town flaunts being an all-year-round coastal region with vibrant businesses.

Suttons Bay is famous for its well-established galleries, boutiques, incredible small-town cinema, and dining venues. The Bay Theatre, which is a few minutes away, is also worth a mention. You can go to Bahle Park to access the TART trail and enjoy hiking trails at any time of the year. Here, you can bike, run, walk, fat tire bike, snowshoe, and skate-ski to Traverse City.

What’s more, Suttons Bay’s famous local brewery is conveniently suited next to TART access. From wine tasting to golfing, the town’s endless views will excite you regardless of the activity you decide to partake.

Suttons Bay Community Highlights

When buying a home in Suttons Bay, the wide variety of community activities draws most potential buyers. The turquoise waters and rolling landscapes offer an exceptional backdrop for plenty of activities. From playing on the beach and sailing to visiting the many art galleries and tasting wine, there are plenty of activities to do in this area.

Walkthrough the ancient downtown district or play golf on the stunning courses. As an adventure enthusiast, take your bike for a thrilling ride down the TART trail or get into a boat and sail through the fantastic turquoise bay.

If you are into arts, Glen Arbor Art Association will be your preferred recreation spot. Situated at the Lower Peninsula, this gem is built next to Lake Michigan and near the Sleeping Bear Dunes National Lakeshore.

Incredible views of Lake Michigan, towering dunes, and stunning lakes are everywhere from this location. Musicians, writers, and artists often come here to work and live.

During the weekend, take your family to the Grand Traverse Lighthouse Museum. This museum is situated in northern Michigan, inside the Leelanau State, nine miles north of Northport, and at the tip of the Leelanau Peninsula. A fact about the museum is that it has been guiding sailors and ships since 1852. Stroll through the restored keeper’s dwelling and go all the way to the tower for an unforgettable view of the Manitou Passage, the Grand Traverse Bay, Lake Michigan, and Cathead Bay.

The Great Lakes Children’s Museum, on the other hand, will create a stimulating effect on your kids. As a tax-exempt and non-profit organization, this museum can impart hands-on, high-quality educational experiences to Suttons Bay kids.

Learn much more about the Leelanau Peninsula Wine Trail, where the cool-climate wines combine well with the local cuisine. The different microclimates, which are exceptionally suited for several wine grapes, make it easy to produce famous wine varieties, such as Pinot Noir, Cabernet Franc, Riesling, and many others. The tasting rooms offer an extraordinary experience, from cozy nooks loaded with allure to pure elegance filled with unmatched views.

The Suttons Bay Marina, located along Lake Michigan and to the east of downtown, features Marina Park and a stunning public beach where you can go swimming, play, or even sunbathe. The shallow water on this beach makes it a must-visit area for families that want to spend the day watching children play in the kids’ area or play beach volleyball.

If you love to gamble, Suttons Bay has got your back, thanks to the Leelanau Sands Casino. This casino offers you a chance to laugh with friends, check your cares, or even fatten your bank balance. With plenty of slot machines and an exceptional selection of table games, such as roulette, craps, blackjack, 3-card poker, and plenty of virtual table games, this casino will surely keep you busy throughout the weekend.

Shopping at Suttons Bay

The Suttons Bay shopping district is undeniably delightful. The district hosts more than 25 retailers who welcome you into great stores that offer plenty of items for a memorable buying experience.

Here, you will find home furnishings, designer outfits, books, an exceptional selection of gourmet meals, toys, and Michigan-made items.

When you shop in this region, you will undoubtedly encounter some delightful treasures to take home. Some popular stores in Suttons Bay include: The Northern Building Supply, Haystacks, Suttons Bay Marketplace, Lime Bean, Forget-Me-Not Florist, Thistledown Shoppe, The Front Porch, Suttons Bay Trading Co., and The Happy Woman Store.

Besides, there are plenty of galleries in Suttons Bay to offer the arts of the countless local artists. The best art galleries you can consider browsing in the area include Michigan Artists Gallery, Case-Daniels, Brenda J. Clark Gallery, The Painted Bird, and Sutton Bay Galleries.

Restaurants at Suttons Bay

Suttons Bay gives foodies a diverse mixture of dining experiences and fabulous restaurants. With more than 14 restaurants, you are spoilt for choices. 

Your options include European-style cafes, delicious breakfasts, continental fare, Italian, Chinese, and other special meals.

Additionally, there are several ice cream parlors, pizza places, candy stores, bakeries, and coffee shops. Wherever you find yourself there is no doubt you will be in culinary heaven.

The local delis give you an easy time to plan a random picnic where you can tour the Suttons Bay Park or beach.

The bottom line is that the restaurants almost offer everything for everyone in your family.

Recreation Activities at Suttons Bay

Taking part in recreational activities regularly offers you a great level of optimism, emotional and mental stability, good memory, confidence, independence, and brilliant decision-making skills. Here are the recreational activities you can participate in Suttons Bay:

Go to Inland Seas Education Association (ISEA)

As a non-profit company, ISEA helps individuals of all ages experience the spirit and science of the great lakes in the region. The knowledge and skills acquired through this experience give one understanding, commitment, and education required for the prolonged stewardship of the great lakes.

Golfing at Bahle Farms

Situated in an attractive region and a few minutes from Traverse City, Bahle Farms offers a majestic golf course with fantastic views that interlock throughout the Cherry Orchard. Due to its stunning landscape, the Bahle Farms is amongst the finest golf resorts you can find in Suttons Bay. The mesmerizing Sutton Bay views, gorgeous terrain, whimsical greens, and rolling hills will make your golf excursion unforgettable.

Visit the Sleeping Bear Dunes National Lakeshore

This national lakeshore is perhaps one of the stunning natural areas you can see in Suttons Bay. Visit the area during the weekend to enjoy an incredible 35 miles of Lake Michigan’s coastline. What’s more, climb the dunes and sightsee the North and South Manitou Islands.

The Sleeping Bear Dunes has been in place since time immemorial, while the Lakeshore is available for public use and preservation of natural resources. Besides the fantastic views offered, this park is delightfully water-oriented.

Schools Near Suttons Bay, Michigan

Most homebuyers in Suttons Bay want properties that will rise in value. Buying properties next to essential amenities, such as schools, public transport, and shops, is a great benefit because no one wants to travel long distances searching for these necessities.

The truth is that most people want the amenities to be right at their doorstep. Thus, buying houses adjacent to these amenities increases future home sales prices.

When looking forward to buying a home in Suttons Bay, countless questions might run through your mind, but the biggest question you need to ask yourself is whether the home is near a school. Due to congestion in urban areas, no child wants to commute long distances to get an education.

Currently, a massive decision for parents is determining the school their kids will attend. Some parents research about their kid’s best possible school even before they are born. Thus, home buyers are looking forward to having popular schools in their neighborhoods. Luckily, Suttons Bay has plenty of good elementary, middle, high, private, and public schools. The area also boasts outstanding universities and colleges.

Focused on Northern Michigan Investment Real Estate

Brook is focused on lifestyle real estate investment properties as most people want a vacation home to make lifelong memories that endure for their entire family, leave a profound legacy for generations, and they want a solid financial investment at the same time.  While the area does have many good realtors, there aren’t many with the unique financial, vacation home investing, and technology marketing background. Brook uses his diverse skill set to help clients properly evaluate and determine whether a vacation home makes financial sense.

"I have significant experience buying and selling Northern Michigan Real Estate and I'd like to help you find the perfect Suttons Bay, Michigan home." Send me a message or give me a call at 231.459.3179 to learn more today."

Start searching for your dream home now.

When it comes to convenience, our site is unparalleled. Whether you're in the comfort of your home, or on the go.
Our site works flawlessly on multiple devices so you can find the information you need.

Start Search