Real Estate Statistics
| Average Price | $698K |
|---|---|
| Lowest Price | $179K |
| Highest Price | $1.1M |
| Total Listings | 7 |
| Avg. Days On Market | 101 |
| Avg. Price/SQFT | $340 |
Property Types (active listings)
Browse Suttons Bay Downtown Homes for Sale
- All Listings
- $100,000 - $200,000
- $400,000 - $500,000
- $600,000 - $700,000
- $700,000 - $800,000
- $800,000 - $900,000
- $900,000 - $1,000,000
- Over $1,000,000
Stunning Deals: Suttons Bay, MI Downtown Homes for Sale (2025)
Introduction to Suttons Bay, MI
Nestled along the crystal-clear shores of Grand Traverse Bay, Suttons Bay, Michigan is more than just a picturesque village—it's a lifestyle. Located on the Leelanau Peninsula, just 20 miles north of Traverse City, Suttons Bay offers a perfect blend of small-town charm and upscale living. With its vibrant downtown, serene waters, and tight-knit community, it’s no surprise that downtown Suttons Bay homes are in high demand.
If you’re searching for a cozy cottage, a modern condo, or a waterfront retreat, you’ll find that Suttons Bay, MI Downtown Homes for Sale offer something truly special. From the moment you arrive, you’ll be enchanted by tree-lined streets, boutique shops, art galleries, and a welcoming atmosphere that makes it hard to leave.
Check out this video for a look at the Suttons Bay community
Real Estate Market Overview in Suttons Bay
Current Market Trends
The Suttons Bay housing market has remained stable and slightly competitive in 2025, with homes in downtown areas seeing a steady rise in value due to increased demand and limited inventory. Most buyers are drawn to the area's walkability and waterfront access, leading to quicker sales and frequent bidding wars.
Average Home Prices
As of early 2025, the average price of a downtown Suttons Bay home is around $550,000, though properties can range widely depending on location, age, and amenities.
Market Forecast for 2025
Experts predict moderate appreciation into 2025 as remote work continues to make scenic small towns like Suttons Bay increasingly desirable. With more professionals relocating from larger metro areas, demand is expected to remain strong.
Benefits of Living in Downtown Suttons Bay
Walkability and Convenience
One of the biggest perks of downtown living is walkability. Residents can stroll to the grocery store, sip wine at a nearby tasting room, or enjoy a fresh croissant from a local bakery—all within minutes.
Access to Local Amenities
From artisan coffee shops to community events, everything you need is within arm’s reach. Plus, the marina and beachfront parks make it easy to enjoy the great outdoors year-round.
Community Lifestyle
Life in Suttons Bay is laid-back yet vibrant. It’s common to see neighbors gathering at the farmers market or enjoying open-air concerts in the summer. The sense of community is palpable, making it ideal for families, retirees, and professionals alike.
Types of Downtown Homes Available
Historic Homes
Charming century-old houses line the downtown streets, many beautifully restored with updated interiors while preserving original character.
Modern Condos
Looking for low-maintenance living? Modern downtown condos with lake views, open layouts, and smart technology offer the perfect blend of comfort and convenience.
Waterfront Properties
Few things beat waking up to a bayfront sunrise. Suttons Bay offers exclusive waterfront homes, often with private docks and stunning panoramic views.
Renovated Cottages
Renovated cottages—many of them originally built as summer homes—offer affordable and stylish living with easy access to the heart of town.
Check out this video for a look at the downtown lifestyle
Price Ranges and What You Get for Your Budget
| Price Range | What You Can Expect |
|---|---|
| Under $300K | Quaint cottages, fixer-uppers, small condos with walkability to downtown |
| $300K–$600K | Mid-size family homes, updated historic properties, some with partial bay views |
| Over $600K (Luxury) | Waterfront estates, high-end modern homes, premium condos with luxury amenities |
Top Neighborhoods in Downtown Suttons Bay
Stony Point
Known for its upscale homes and spectacular views of the bay, Stony Point is one of the most sought-after areas in Suttons Bay. With private access to the water and quiet tree-lined streets, it offers a secluded feel while being just a short stroll from the village center.
Broadway District
This area pulses with historic charm and vibrant street life. Broadway Street is home to some of the oldest houses in the area, many of which have been thoughtfully modernized. You'll also find cozy cafes, art galleries, and quaint retail shops nearby.
Marina Area
If waterfront access is a must, the Marina District delivers. Residents enjoy boat slips, easy kayaking access, and homes with direct bay views. It’s ideal for water lovers who also want to be within walking distance of restaurants and parks.
Popular Features in Suttons Bay Downtown Homes
Porches & Lake Views
Many homes feature wrap-around porches perfect for watching the sunset over the bay. These spaces are ideal for entertaining or just relaxing with a good book.
Open Concept Interiors
Modern buyers will love the spacious, open-concept layouts that many renovated homes now offer. Large windows, vaulted ceilings, and natural light are common design elements.
Energy Efficiency & Smart Tech
Eco-conscious upgrades like solar panels, smart thermostats, and high-efficiency HVAC systems are becoming standard in downtown homes. These additions not only save money but also increase resale value.
Investment Potential and ROI
Short-Term Rentals & Airbnb
Thanks to Suttons Bay’s popularity as a summer and fall travel destination, downtown homes perform exceptionally well as vacation rentals. Properties near the waterfront or village center often have over 70% occupancy during peak months.
Long-Term Value Appreciation
The steady appreciation rate and low home inventory in Leelanau County make Suttons Bay a smart long-term investment. Whether you’re buying to live or lease, ROI prospects are strong.
Local Amenities and Attractions
Boutique Shops
Downtown Suttons Bay boasts a charming mix of local boutiques, from antique stores to high-end apparel shops. It’s a shopper’s haven with a distinctly local flavor.
Restaurants & Wineries
Whether you’re craving farm-to-table fare, artisan coffee, or fine wine, Suttons Bay delivers. Popular spots like Martha’s Table and Hop Lot Brewing Company draw both locals and tourists year-round.
Bayfront Parks & Trails
Nature lovers rejoice! Sutton Park, Bahle Park, and Leelanau Trail offer scenic outdoor experiences, including biking, hiking, and beach days with panoramic lake views.
Education and Schools Nearby
Public and Private Options
Families in Suttons Bay can choose from well-rated public schools and a few charter/private institutions. Suttons Bay Public Schools serve grades K-12 with a focus on personalized education.
Ratings and Parent Reviews
The schools in the area consistently receive high marks for their teacher engagement, community involvement, and small class sizes, making it an attractive destination for families with kids.
Transportation and Connectivity
Access to Traverse City
With Traverse City just a 25-minute drive away, commuting is simple. This proximity also gives Suttons Bay residents access to a larger airport, big-box stores, and major employers.
Walk/Bike-Friendliness
Downtown Suttons Bay is exceptionally pedestrian and cyclist-friendly, with well-maintained sidewalks, bike paths, and bike racks throughout the village.
Public Transit Options
Bay Area Transportation Authority (BATA) offers local bus service between Suttons Bay and neighboring towns, making it easier for non-drivers to get around.
Step-by-Step Guide to Buying a Downtown Home
Financing Options
Buyers can choose from conventional mortgages, FHA loans, or even special first-time homebuyer programs in Michigan. Pre-approval is highly recommended in this competitive market.
Working with a Local Realtor
Hiring a local agent is essential. They’ll understand the intricacies of historic districts, seasonal market changes, and local regulations, ensuring a smoother buying process.
Home Inspections and Closing Process
Make sure to schedule a thorough home inspection, especially for older homes. The closing process typically takes 30–45 days once an offer is accepted.
Local Real Estate Agents and Agencies
Navigating the real estate market in a niche location like downtown Suttons Bay requires local expertise and insider knowledge. One standout in the community is:
Brook Walsh – Northern Michigan Real Estate Specialist
Brook Walsh is a highly respected local real estate professional with a deep understanding of luxury and waterfront properties in Suttons Bay and the surrounding areas. With a reputation built on trust, results, and exceptional client service, Brook offers unparalleled guidance to both buyers and sellers looking for prime downtown locations.
Whether you're searching for a historic cottage, a lakefront retreat, or a modern investment property, Brook’s extensive portfolio and market insight make him a go-to expert in Leelanau County.
Future Developments and Zoning Information
Planned Projects
While downtown Suttons Bay maintains a “quaint” charm, new mixed-use developments and residential expansions are underway. These projects aim to support tourism and affordable housing.
Historic District Regulations
Some homes fall under the Suttons Bay Village Historic District, which has specific guidelines for exterior renovations and preservation efforts. Buyers should review local zoning codes before purchasing.
Buyer Testimonials and Success Stories
"We moved here from Chicago and never looked back. Our downtown cottage is two blocks from the beach and walking distance to everything." – Sarah T., new resident
"Our investment property now brings in over $40K annually as a short-term rental—plus we get to enjoy it during the offseason." – Mark & Tina H., investors
FAQs About Suttons Bay, MI Downtown Homes for Sale
1. Are downtown homes in Suttons Bay expensive?
A. Prices vary, but expect to pay between $300K–$700K depending on size, location, and condition.
2. Is Suttons Bay a good place for families?
A. Yes! The town is safe, has great schools, and offers plenty of family-friendly amenities.
3. Can I rent out my Suttons Bay property as a vacation rental?
A. Absolutely. Many homes are used for seasonal rentals, especially those near the marina or downtown.
4. How competitive is the real estate market?
A. It’s moderately competitive, especially in spring and summer. Act fast if you find the right property.
5. Are there lakefront homes in downtown Suttons Bay?
A. Yes, though they’re limited and tend to sell quickly. Expect premium prices.
6. What kind of architecture is common downtown?
A. You’ll find Victorian, Craftsman, and cottage-style homes—many beautifully updated inside.
Conclusion: Why Now is the Time to Buy in Suttons Bay
With its walkable lifestyle, strong community vibe, and steady real estate appreciation, there’s never been a better time to explore Suttons Bay, MI Downtown Homes for Sale. Whether you’re looking for a forever home, a vacation property, or an investment opportunity, downtown Suttons Bay offers unmatched value and charm.
Don't wait—secure your place in one of Michigan’s most picturesque waterfront towns today!
Explore homes in the downtown lifestyle communities below or contact Brook Walsh to help with your search. You can also reach Brook by phone at (231) 459-3179 for all of your Northern Michigan real estate needs.
Browse All Downtown Communities
- Downtown Alanson
- Downtown Alpena
- Downtown Atlanta
- Downtown Bay Harbor
- Downtown Beaver Island
- Downtown Bellaire
- Downtown Beulah
- Downtown Boyne City
- Downtown Cadillac
- Downtown Central Lake
- Downtown Charlevoix
- Downtown Cheboygan
- Downtown Cross Village
- Downtown East Jordan
- Downtown Elk Rapids
- Downtown Ellsworth
- Downtown Empire
- Downtown Frankfort
- Downtown Gaylord
- Downtown Glen Arbor
- Downtown Grayling
- Downtown Harbor Springs
- Downtown Hillman
- Downtown Honor
- Downtown Houghton Lake
- Downtown Indian River
- Downtown Interlochen
- Downtown Johannesburg
- Downtown Kalkaska
- Downtown Kewadin
- Downtown Kingsley
- Downtown Lake Ann
- Downtown Lake City
- Downtown Leland
- Downtown Levering
- Downtown Lewiston
- Downtown Mancelona
- Downtown Manistee
- Downtown Manton
- Downtown Maple City
- Downtown Northport
- Downtown Onaway
- Downtown Onekama
- Downtown Petoskey
- Downtown Rogers City
- Downtown Roscommon
- Downtown Suttons Bay
- Downtown Tawas City
- Downtown Thompsonville
- Downtown Traverse City
- Downtown Walloon Lake
- Downtown Williamsburg