Explore Bay Harbor, MI Real Estate | Luxury Homes on Lake Michigan

Bay Harbor

Bay Harbor is a premier waterfront community on Lake Michigan, known for upscale homes, world-class amenities, and stunning views. This master-planned village offers marina access, championship golf, boutique shopping, and fine dining—all just minutes from Petoskey and Charlevoix.

Real estate options include custom lakefront estates, golf course homes, and luxury condos overlooking the harbor. With strong property values and a resort-style atmosphere, Bay Harbor is the ideal choice for those seeking refined Northern Michigan living.

Real Estate Statistics

Average Price	$2.3M
Lowest Price	$65K
Highest Price	$10M
Total Listings	24
Avg. Price/SQFT	$695

Property Types (active listings)

Browse Bay Harbor Real Estate Listings

• All Listings
• Under $100,000
• $100,000 - $200,000
• $200,000 - $300,000
• $300,000 - $400,000
• $400,000 - $500,000
• $500,000 - $600,000
• Over $1,000,000

Bedrooms

Bathrooms

Price Range

Save Search

Sort by:

Price, high to low

$9,995,000

6344 Bay Ridge Drive, Bay Harbor

5 Beds 7 Baths 8,900 SqFt RESIDENTIAL MLS® # 475754

$9,250,000

4050 Peninsula Drive, Bay Harbor

5 Beds 7 Baths 8,387 SqFt RESIDENTIAL MLS® # 476242

$8,900,000

1201 Shores Drive, Bay Harbor

5 Beds 8 Baths 6,080 SqFt RESIDENTIAL MLS® # 475627

$7,900,000

6744 Preserve Drive N, Bay Harbor

7 Beds 9 Baths 10,571 SqFt RESIDENTIAL MLS® # 476136

$3,395,000

852 Bluffs Court, Bay Harbor

4 Beds 5 Baths 4,220 SqFt RESIDENTIAL MLS® # 476037

$1,849,000

748 Sunset Way, Bay Harbor

5 Beds 5 Baths 3,383 SqFt RESIDENTIAL MLS® # 475225

1 2 3 4

Next

Check out this video for a look at Bay Harbor real estate, or read on to learn more about life in Bay Harbor. 

---

---

Bay Harbor Real Estate

Often called the crown jewel of northern Michigan’s lakeside luxury, Bay Harbor is a resort community near Lake Michigan and Little Traverse Bay. It is one of the prime vacation spots in Michigan as it hosts people from across the country all year round. From lying under the sun in the summers to escaping into a winter wonderland, Bay Harbor provides activities for all kinds of vacationers. 

Spectacular views of the surrounding lands, top-class golf courses, a deepwater marina, and an experience of boutique shopping are only some of the attractions in the region.

You can go golfing in the Harbor Golf Club which is one of the premium spots of the Bay Harbor and recognized as one of the most picturesque ones in the country. Or you can take strolls in the brick-paved streets in the Village to take in nature’s bounty or spend the day shopping. For a more adventurous day, head over to the marina to take a boat into the cool blue waters of the nearby lakes.

A local treasure of activities and beauty, Bay Harbor is also a popular place of real estate opportunities. Houses, condos or waterfront lots, you will find many properties ready for buying or renting. Brook Walsh can help you find your perfect match so you can become a part of the luxury community. Brook can also help you sell a property to others looking to invest in Bay Harbor real estate. 

There are many different housing options in Bay Harbor including condominiums for sale, downtown homes for sale, golf homes for sale, luxury homes for sale, resort homes for sale, and waterfront homes for sale.

According to the Northern Michigan Multi-Listing Service, the average sales price for a home in Bay Harbor is $1,480,662 with a high of $8,350,000 in 2003 and a low of $257,000 in 2011. The average sales price for a condominium in Bay Harbor is $412,792 with a high of $2,025,000 in 2013 and a low of $24,000 in 2001.

Introduction to Bay Harbor

Overview of Bay Harbor, Michigan

Nestled on the scenic shores of Lake Michigan between Petoskey and Charlevoix, Bay Harbor is a prestigious lakeside community in Northern Michigan. Known for its luxury real estate, world-class marina, and breathtaking views, Bay Harbor is a haven for those seeking tranquility, elegance, and year-round recreational living.

Originally developed from a reclaimed cement factory, Bay Harbor has transformed into a master-planned community with timeless appeal. Its unique blend of upscale living and natural beauty has made it one of the most sought-after destinations for homebuyers and investors alike.

The Unique Charm of Northern Michigan's Lakefront Community

Bay Harbor isn't just another lakeside development. Its charm lies in the seamless fusion of waterfront elegance, small-town warmth, and vibrant community spirit. Whether it's the cobblestone streets, upscale boutiques, or picturesque sunsets over Little Traverse Bay, Bay Harbor offers a lifestyle that captivates both permanent residents and seasonal visitors.

Real Estate Market Overview

Current Trends in Bay Harbor Real Estate

The Bay Harbor real estate market continues to show robust growth. High demand and limited inventory have created a competitive landscape. Lakefront homes and luxury condos are particularly hot commodities. Thanks to its strong appeal to both retirees and investors, Bay Harbor sees consistent interest from buyers across the Midwest and beyond.

Recent years have seen a shift toward year-round living, with more families choosing Bay Harbor as a primary residence rather than a seasonal retreat. The increasing popularity has bolstered property values and made it a prime target for long-term investment.

Property Values and Investment Potential

Bay Harbor properties are holding their value exceptionally well, outperforming many other vacation home markets. Waterfront properties, in particular, command premium prices due to limited availability and high demand. Whether you’re buying for personal use or as an investment, the long-term appreciation and rental income potential make Bay Harbor real estate a smart financial move.

Types of Properties Available

Waterfront Homes and Lakefront Estates

Bay Harbor boasts some of the most exquisite lakefront properties in Michigan. These homes often feature private docks, expansive decks, custom architecture, and direct access to the water. The serenity of lakeside living is unmatched, and these properties are perfect for boating enthusiasts and nature lovers alike.

Luxury Condominiums and Villas

For those who prefer low-maintenance living without sacrificing luxury, Bay Harbor's condos and villas offer the perfect solution. Many of these properties include high-end finishes, concierge services, and panoramic views of Little Traverse Bay. They're ideal for seasonal residents or retirees looking for comfort and convenience.

Golf Course Properties and Custom Builds

Homes overlooking Bay Harbor’s scenic golf courses provide a mix of lush landscapes and architectural splendor. Buyers can also purchase vacant lots and build their dream home tailored to personal tastes, all while enjoying the perks of living in a luxury community.

Neighborhoods and Developments in Bay Harbor

Village at Bay Harbor

The heart of the community, the Village at Bay Harbor, is where you’ll find charming shops, fine dining, and cultural events. It’s pedestrian-friendly and ideal for those who love to be in the center of activity.

The Cliffs, The Preserve, and Other Elite Areas

These private enclaves offer exclusive lakefront and wooded properties with larger lots and enhanced privacy. Residents enjoy serene environments while still having access to all Bay Harbor amenities.

Gated Communities and Private Residences

Gated neighborhoods offer added security and exclusivity, appealing to high-net-worth individuals who value discretion and peace of mind.

Living the Bay Harbor Lifestyle

Yacht Club and Marina Amenities

The Bay Harbor Yacht Club is a centerpiece of the community, offering world-class marina services, fine dining, fitness facilities, and a calendar packed with social events. Whether you own a boat or just appreciate the nautical lifestyle, this club enhances the Bay Harbor experience.

Dining, Shopping, and Cultural Attractions

Bay Harbor features gourmet restaurants, boutique stores, art galleries, and music festivals. The cultural richness of this small town makes it far more than a summer destination—it’s a place to enjoy year-round.

Year-Round Recreational Activities

From boating and fishing in the summer to skiing and snowshoeing in the winter, Bay Harbor supports an active lifestyle. Golfers, hikers, and nature lovers will find countless ways to enjoy the outdoors in every season.

Education and Local Schools

Public and Private School Options

Families moving to Bay Harbor have access to excellent educational options. Nearby Petoskey Schools offer strong academic programs, and several private institutions provide faith-based and alternative education choices. The Petoskey public school system is one of the areas best and largest. It includes the following schools: 

• Central Elementary School
• Lincoln Elementary School
• Ottawa Elementary School
• Sheridan Elementary School
• Montessori
• Petoskey Middle School
• Petoskey High School 

Nearby Colleges and Continuing Education

North Central Michigan College is a short drive away, offering adult learning programs, associate degrees, and workforce training. This makes Bay Harbor a viable location for lifelong learners.

Climate and Seasonal Highlights

What to Expect Each Season

Bay Harbor enjoys a classic northern Michigan climate, offering distinct four-season living. Summers are warm and sunny, perfect for boating, beach days, and outdoor festivals. Autumn brings vibrant foliage, ideal for scenic drives and harvest events. Winters are snowy and serene, drawing skiers and snowshoers, while spring breathes fresh life into the community with blooming landscapes.

This seasonal variety enhances the lifestyle appeal of Bay Harbor and supports year-round activities for residents and visitors alike.

How Weather Impacts Property Use and Value

The seasonal charm not only elevates the lifestyle but also maintains high demand for seasonal rentals. Lakefront homes become hot vacation properties in summer, while cozy chalets and condos see high occupancy in winter. This balanced seasonality positively influences property value appreciation and rental income throughout the year.

Accessibility and Transportation

Getting to Bay Harbor

Bay Harbor is conveniently accessible by car via US-31, and it’s just a short drive from Pellston Regional Airport, which offers flights connecting to major hubs like Detroit. For private aviation, there’s also the nearby Harbor Springs Airport.

For visitors and residents alike, the community offers a peaceful retreat without being too remote—making it a perfect blend of accessibility and exclusivity.

Proximity to Petoskey, Traverse City, and Other Hubs

Located just minutes from the charming city of Petoskey and less than two hours from Traverse City, Bay Harbor benefits from its proximity to larger urban centers. These nearby cities offer additional dining, shopping, medical facilities, and cultural experiences, enhancing Bay Harbor’s livability.

Cost of Living and Property Taxes

Comparing Costs with Other Lake Michigan Communities

While Bay Harbor is a premium market, its cost of living remains competitive with other upscale lakefront areas in Michigan and even across the Great Lakes region. Residents enjoy access to luxurious amenities at a value that often surpasses similar communities in Illinois or Wisconsin.

Real Estate Taxes and HOA Fees

Property taxes in Bay Harbor are relatively manageable and contribute to maintaining the area's high-quality infrastructure. Homeowners’ Association (HOA) fees vary by neighborhood but generally cover amenities like security, snow removal, and landscaping—making life in Bay Harbor hassle-free.

Rental Market and Vacation Homes

Investment in Short-Term Rentals

Bay Harbor’s popularity as a summer and holiday destination creates a lucrative short-term rental market. Properties near the waterfront or within walking distance of the Village often command premium nightly rates on platforms like Airbnb and Vrbo.

Owning a Second Home in Bay Harbor

Many buyers choose Bay Harbor for their second home or vacation getaway. With flexible property management services available locally, maintaining a second residence here is both easy and profitable. It’s a low-stress way to enjoy lakeside luxury while generating passive income.

Why Buy in Bay Harbor Now?

Economic Growth in Northern Michigan

Northern Michigan has seen a surge in tourism, development, and local business growth. This upward trend adds to Bay Harbor’s appeal as not only a relaxing place to live, but also a thriving investment hub.

Market Appreciation Trends

Bay Harbor real estate has experienced steady appreciation over the past decade, even during economic downturns. The stability of this market, especially for luxury and waterfront properties, makes it a safe harbor for long-term investment.

Long-Term Investment Security

With ongoing demand, limited land availability, and high construction standards, Bay Harbor offers enduring value. The market continues to attract both domestic and international buyers, solidifying its status as a premier real estate destination.

Real Estate Agents and Agencies

Choosing a Local Expert Realtor

Buying or selling property in Bay Harbor requires local insight. Partnering with a real estate agent who understands the nuances of the area—from zoning laws to seasonal trends—can make all the difference.

Benefits of Working with a Bay Harbor Specialist

Specialist agents offer personalized tours, access to off-market listings, and deep knowledge of individual neighborhoods. They also maintain connections with service providers, lenders, and inspectors—streamlining the entire buying or selling process.

Tips for Buyers and Sellers

What Buyers Should Know Before Purchasing

• Do your research: Understand HOA rules and future development plans.

• Work with a local agent: They’ll help you find hidden gems.

• Inspect thoroughly: Waterfront properties require detailed inspections.

Preparing Your Property for Sale

• Staging is key: Highlight the lifestyle appeal of your home.

• Professional photos and drone videos: Essential for showcasing views.

• Choose the right season: Spring and summer are prime for listings.

Future Developments and Expansion

Upcoming Projects and Community Enhancements

Bay Harbor continues to evolve with plans for expanded marina services, new retail spaces, and improved community facilities. These enhancements ensure property values stay strong and resident satisfaction remains high.

Zoning Laws and Property Development Trends

The local zoning laws are designed to preserve Bay Harbor’s charm and prevent overdevelopment. New builds must meet high architectural standards, protecting the character of the community and the integrity of investments.

Testimonials from Homeowners

Real Stories from Bay Harbor Residents

"We bought our lakefront home five years ago and have never looked back. The sunsets, the neighbors, the peace—it’s everything we hoped for." – The Andersens, Chicago, IL

"Bay Harbor is a hidden gem. It has the elegance of a Hamptons summer town but with the friendly feel of Northern Michigan." – Mark W., Grand Rapids, MI

Why They Chose Bay Harbor

Most homeowners say they were drawn to Bay Harbor for its beauty but stayed for the lifestyle. Whether it’s the sense of community, the low-maintenance luxury, or the unbeatable lake views, Bay Harbor wins hearts quickly.

Bay Harbor Community Highlights

Situated along five miles of stunningly beautiful Lake Michigan shoreline between Petoskey and Charlevoix, Bay Harbor is an idyllic destination for vacationers, visitors, and residents alike. With stunning views, world-class amenities, unique accommodations, unrivaled recreational opportunities, and a calendar full of events, it’s the perfect place to mix business with pleasure, connect with friends and family or simply unplug.  

The Village at Bay Harbor is a magical place and one of the most memorable dining and shopping destinations in Northern Michigan. Brick paved streets and spectacular views create a distinctive setting for its fashionable boutiques, exceptional specialty stores, and popular waterfront restaurants.  Living in the Village is for people who want to be a part of all the fun and amenities including a short walk or GEM car ride to shopping, dining, the marina, and performances at the Great Lakes Center for the Arts.  

Bay Harbor Lake Marina is a remarkable place to be. Carved into the tranquil waters of Bay Harbor Lake that channels into Lake Michigan, it is a connection to one of the country's best places to cruise. Boaters at the marina enjoy the wonderful amenities the marina offers, but they also enjoy being part of the community.

Bay Harbor Yacht Club is an award-winning private club with first-class amenities and dockside concierge services.  Overlooking the marina and Lake Michigan, the Yacht Club offers breathtaking views, exceptional dining, waterfront, and recreational activities, and an extensive calendar of year-round events. 

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Is Bay Harbor good for year-round living?

Yes! While it's a popular seasonal spot, many residents live here full-time and enjoy all four seasons with plenty of activities year-round.

2. Can I rent out my Bay Harbor home when not using it?

Absolutely. Many owners generate income through vacation rentals, especially in summer. Just be sure to check local HOA rules.

3. Are there financing options for buying property in Bay Harbor?

Yes, traditional mortgages, jumbo loans, and even specialty financing for second homes are available through local banks and national lenders.

4. What’s the best neighborhood for lake views?

The Cliffs and The Preserve are among the top choices for stunning panoramic views of Lake Michigan.

5. How much do Bay Harbor properties cost?

Prices vary widely. Condos may start in the $400,000 range, while luxury waterfront estates can exceed $5 million.

6. Are pets allowed in the community?

Most areas within Bay Harbor are pet-friendly, though individual properties and HOAs may have specific rules.

Conclusion

Bay Harbor Real Estate (located in Northern Michigan) is more than an investment—it’s an invitation to experience lakeside luxury in one of the Midwest’s most desirable communities. Whether you’re searching for a vacation home, a year-round residence, or a smart investment, Bay Harbor offers a unique blend of natural beauty, upscale living, and strong market potential. With its expanding amenities, stable growth, and welcoming charm, there's never been a better time to make your move.

Petoskey Annual Events

Arts in the Park, Watershed Council 40th Anniversary Meeting & Gala, Festival on the Bay, Emmet Charlevoix County Fair, The Bay 2 Braman Bolt: "A Race to Preserve History"