Discover Spider Lake Homes for Sale in Scenic Traverse City, MI

Spider Lake

Tucked away just 20 minutes southeast of downtown Traverse City, the Spider Lake community offers a peaceful, nature-filled lifestyle with all the conveniences of nearby city amenities. Known for its clear waters, wooded surroundings, and welcoming atmosphere, Spider Lake is home to a mix of full-time residents, seasonal homeowners, and vacationers seeking the perfect Northern Michigan escape.

The community features a variety of homes, from charming lakeside cottages to upscale waterfront estates, many with private docks and panoramic views. Residents enjoy year-round outdoor recreation including boating, fishing, swimming, snowmobiling, and cross-country skiing—right from their backyards. Spider Lake’s laid-back environment and strong neighborhood spirit make it ideal for families, retirees, and investors alike.

Real Estate Statistics

Average Price	$624K
Lowest Price	$289K
Highest Price	$1.3M
Total Listings	8
Avg. Days On Market	25
Avg. Price/SQFT	$518

Property Types (active listings)

Browse Spider Lake Homes for Sale

Bedrooms

Bathrooms

Price Range

Save Search

Sort by:

Price, high to low

$1,269,900

↓ $29,100

3764 Harolds Road, Traverse City

2 Beds 2.5 Baths 2,696 SqFt Residential MLS® # 1937732

New

$785,000

329 Birchwood Lane, Traverse City

3 Beds 2 Baths 1,758 SqFt Residential MLS® # 1937673

New Pending

$589,900

3900 Harolds Road, Traverse City

2 Beds 2 Baths 1,040 SqFt Residential MLS® # 1938459

$575,000

4367 Balsam Circle, Traverse City

2 Beds 1 Bath 789 SqFt Residential MLS® # 1936656

$499,900

4411 Lakeview Trail, Traverse City

2 Beds 1 Bath 1,044 SqFt Residential MLS® # 1936090

$499,000

↓ $51,000

4391 Balsam Circle, Traverse City

3 Beds 1 Bath 900 SqFt Residential MLS® # 1935370

New

$487,500

4307 Balsam Circle, Traverse City

2 Beds 1 Bath 864 SqFt Residential MLS® # 1938427

New Pending

$289,000

260 Lauri Wil Lane, Traverse City

2 Beds 1 Bath 864 SqFt Residential MLS® # 1939450

Spider Lake Homes for Sale | Traverse City, Michigan Hidden Gem with 17 Must-Know Insights

Introduction to Spider Lake Real Estate

Nestled in the heart of Grand Traverse County, Spider Lake offers more than just a picturesque landscape—it offers a lifestyle. When it comes to Spider Lake homes for sale, buyers are drawn to its tranquil waters, tight-knit community, and close proximity to Traverse City.

Whether you're searching for a cozy lakeside cottage or a luxury waterfront estate, this vibrant real estate market offers something for everyone.

With real estate on the rise in Northern Michigan, Spider Lake is becoming a top contender for primary residences, vacation homes, and income-generating rental properties. The region combines rustic charm with modern amenities, making it perfect for year-round enjoyment or seasonal getaways.

Let’s dive into why Spider Lake is quickly becoming one of Traverse City’s most desirable areas for real estate investment.

Why Buyers Are Flocking to Spider Lake

• Unspoiled Natural Beauty: With over 450 acres of glistening water and countless tree-lined coves, Spider Lake looks like something out of a postcard.

• Proximity to Traverse City: Just 20 minutes from downtown, the lake offers a peaceful retreat without sacrificing city amenities.

• Affordability Compared to Other Lakes: Homes on Spider Lake are generally more affordable than similar properties on Torch or Glen Lakes.

• Recreational Opportunities: Perfect for pontooning, kayaking, paddleboarding, and year-round fishing.

Location & Lifestyle Overview

Where Is Spider Lake Located?

Spider Lake is situated southeast of Traverse City, Michigan, in East Bay Township. It’s easily accessible via Garfield Road and just a quick drive from Cherry Capital Airport. This convenience makes it a hot pick for second-home buyers and vacationers from downstate and neighboring states.

Year-Round Activities and Attractions

From swimming and boating in the summer to snowmobiling and cross-country skiing in the winter, Spider Lake delivers all-season fun. Nearby, you'll find:

• Timber Ridge Resort for winter sports and trail access

• VASA Trail System for hiking and biking

• Traverse City for shopping, dining, and events

What Makes This Area Unique?

Unlike more developed lakefront areas, Spider Lake retains a cozy, cabin-in-the-woods vibe. The community prides itself on its low-key atmosphere, where residents wave hello and dock parties are a summer staple.

Property Types Around Spider Lake

Lakefront Homes

These are the crown jewels of Spider Lake real estate. Expect:

• Private docks

• Panoramic lake views

• Outdoor decks, fire pits, and hot tubs

• Home prices ranging from $500,000 to over $1M depending on size and updates

Cabins and Cottages

Perfect for seasonal getaways, many of these properties feature:

• 2-3 bedrooms

• Wood-burning stoves

• Rustic aesthetics

• Price range: $250,000–$500,000

New Construction and Modern Builds

For buyers wanting sleek finishes and energy efficiency, custom builds are popping up around the lake’s western and southern shores. These often include:

• Smart home features

• Energy Star appliances

• Vaulted ceilings and open-concept living

Investment and Rental Properties

The area is zoned for short-term rentals, making it an ideal location for vacation rental investments. Properties that sleep 6+ guests near the water tend to have high occupancy rates between May and October.

Price Trends and Market Insights

Current Home Prices on Spider Lake

As of 2025, median home prices on Spider Lake hover around $610,000, with lakefront properties commanding the highest values. Factors influencing pricing include:

• Lake frontage length

• Dock and beach access

• Modern upgrades or renovations

Historical Market Performance

Over the last five years, Spider Lake has seen:

• A steady 6-8% annual increase in property values

• A surge in interest post-COVID as remote work became normalized

• Increased out-of-state buyer activity

Buying vs. Renting on Spider Lake

Neighborhood Features and Amenities

Local Schools and Education Quality

Families moving to Spider Lake benefit from:

• Traverse City Area Public Schools (TCAPS)—renowned for academic excellence

• Access to charter and Montessori schools

• Proximity to Northwestern Michigan College for continuing education

Proximity to Downtown Traverse City

A 20-minute drive puts you in the heart of:

• Award-winning restaurants

• Cherry Festival events

• Local breweries and boutique shops

Outdoor Amenities and Trails

Spider Lake is surrounded by trails, campgrounds, and parks like:

• Brown Bridge Quiet Area

• Boardman Valley Nature Preserve

• Sand Lakes Quiet Area

Living on the Water: The Spider Lake Lifestyle

Boating, Fishing, and Water Sports

Spider Lake is a true freshwater playground. Its calm, spring-fed waters span over 450 acres and are ideal for:

• Pontoon boating: Great for cruising and social gatherings

• Fishing: Home to bass, pike, perch, and panfish; ice fishing is also popular in winter

• Water skiing and wakeboarding: There are no wake restrictions on much of the lake

• Kayaking and paddleboarding: Enjoy the quiet coves and wildlife from a close-up view

Whether you’re an adrenaline junkie or prefer peaceful paddles at sunrise, Spider Lake supports a variety of recreational lifestyles.

Wildlife and Scenic Beauty

Living here means sharing your space with nature. Residents often report sightings of:

• Bald eagles soaring above

• Loons echoing their haunting calls at dusk

• Whitetail deer near the shorelines

• Turtles sunbathing on logs

Plus, the sunsets here? They’re nothing short of spectacular, especially when viewed from a private dock or screened-in porch.

Tips for Maintaining Waterfront Property

Owning a lakefront home comes with added responsibilities. Here's how to protect your investment:

• Install proper drainage to prevent erosion

• Use native plants for landscaping to protect the shoreline

• Winterize your dock and plumbing systems to prevent off-season damage

• Check zoning and permit requirements before adding any structures or seawalls

Many residents also invest in whole-house dehumidifiers or moisture control systems to keep the lake air from affecting their interiors.

Building or Remodeling a Home at Spider Lake

Construction Regulations and Permits

Before breaking ground, you’ll need to:

• Submit site plans to East Bay Township

• Obtain a soil erosion and sedimentation control permit

• Ensure compliance with 50-foot setback rules from the high-water mark

Work with professionals familiar with the Grand Traverse County permitting process to avoid delays.

Best Local Builders and Contractors

Some reputable builders specializing in lakeside construction include:

• Bayside Builders of Traverse City

• Easling Construction Company

• Socks Construction

They understand how to maximize lake views, protect the shoreline, and work efficiently within zoning regulations.

Renovation Projects with the Best ROI

If you’re purchasing a fixer-upper, here are the smartest upgrades:

• Adding a screened porch or four-season room

• Updating kitchens and bathrooms

• Installing energy-efficient windows and insulation

• Rebuilding docks and enhancing outdoor living spaces

Modern buyers love properties that blend rustic character with modern convenience.

Spider Lake Real Estate for Investors

Vacation Rentals and ROI Potential

Spider Lake is a goldmine for vacation rental income. Key factors that drive profitability:

• Peak seasons: Summer, fall foliage season, and winter holidays

• High occupancy rates: Especially for homes with hot tubs, firepits, and lake access

• Average nightly rate: $350–$600+ depending on size and amenities

Occupancy Rates and Seasonality

Winter sports draw visitors, especially those using the nearby VASA trails or skiing at Shanty Creek and Crystal Mountain.

Property Management Options

Not interested in DIY hosting? Consider using a local service like NorthernMichiganEscapes.com, which offers:

• Full-service vacation rental management

• Professional photography and dynamic pricing

• Cleaning and guest support

• High ROI strategies and reporting dashboards

Homebuying Process in Traverse City

Working with a Local Real Estate Expert

Navigating the Spider Lake market requires a local touch. That’s where BrookWalsh.com shines. With in-depth knowledge of:

• Hidden listings not on public MLS

• Lake access rules and easements

• Community dynamics and seasonal trends

Brook helps you secure the right property at the right price.

Mortgage Pre-Approval and Financing Tips

Before you shop:

• Get pre-approved through a local lender familiar with lake properties

• Understand loan limits and potential for higher down payments on second homes

• Consider lenders like Honor Bank or TCF Bank that specialize in Northern Michigan financing

Hidden Costs to Watch For

Waterfront homes come with a few extras:

• Dock maintenance and insurance

• Septic inspections and potential upgrades

• Higher home insurance premiums

• HOA fees or road maintenance assessments

Work with your agent to build a budget that includes these items.

Real-Life Homeowner Experiences

Testimonials from Residents

There’s no better insight into life on Spider Lake than hearing from the people who call it home. Here’s what some residents have shared:

“We moved here from downstate and have never looked back. Morning coffee on the dock, loons calling in the distance—it’s a dream come true.”
– Amanda T., full-time resident

“We use our cottage as a summer rental and getaway. It’s booked solid from June through September, and the income covers our mortgage and then some.”
– Brian L., investor-owner

“Our kids grew up tubing and fishing here every summer. Now we’re retired and enjoy the peaceful winters just as much.”
– Carol and Dan M., long-term owners

Moving to Spider Lake – What to Expect

Newcomers can expect a welcoming community vibe with a laid-back lifestyle. Here’s a quick rundown of what to expect when making Spider Lake your new home:

• A mix of seasonal and year-round residents

• Casual, community-driven events like pontoon parades and shoreline cleanups

• Slower pace of life—but only 20 minutes from the action of Traverse City

Seasonal vs. Year-Round Living

Many buyers initially purchase a summer home here, only to fall in love and make it their full-time residence. Here’s a comparison:

Environmental Factors and Lake Conservation

Water Quality and Conservation Efforts

Spider Lake is one of the cleaner inland lakes in Northern Michigan, thanks in part to the efforts of the Spider Lake Property Owners Association. Initiatives include:

• Annual water testing

• Invasive species monitoring

• Community awareness programs

Homeowners are encouraged to avoid chemical fertilizers and install shoreline buffers to minimize runoff.

Sustainable Home Practices

Eco-conscious homeowners can take simple steps to preserve the lake’s health:

• Use permeable pavers instead of concrete for driveways

• Install rain barrels and greywater systems

• Opt for low-phosphate detergents

• Maintain septic systems regularly (every 3–5 years)

HOAs and Community Guidelines

Not every part of Spider Lake is governed by an HOA, but where they exist, typical rules may include:

• No motorized watercraft after dark

• Limits on short-term rental durations

• Setbacks for docks and fire pits

• Guidelines for exterior home colors and landscaping

Always check with your agent or township officials about applicable restrictions.

Nearby Communities and Comparable Lakes

Arbutus Lake vs. Spider Lake

Arbutus Lake is just a few miles west of Spider Lake and offers a similar vibe. Here’s how they compare:

Silver Lake and Surrounding Areas

Silver Lake offers more upscale developments and larger luxury homes but comes with a higher price tag and more traffic during peak season. Spider Lake, by contrast, is still under the radar—offering better value for savvy buyers.

Pros and Cons of Each Area

Real Estate Agent’s Guide to Navigating the Market

Choosing the Right Agent

Selecting a local expert is key to making a smart purchase. Look for someone who:

• Lives or owns property in the area

• Understands waterfront regulations

• Has exclusive access to off-market properties

• Offers digital tools for remote buyers

How BrookWalsh.com Helps Buyers

When you work with Brook Walsh, you get:

• Access to hidden listings and upcoming opportunities

• In-depth market analysis and pricing strategy

• Expert negotiation for both buyers and sellers

• Connections to local lenders, inspectors, and contractors

Brook’s background in technology and real estate means your purchase is smooth, data-driven, and personalized.

Exclusive Listings and Insider Knowledge

Brook often lists properties before they hit Zillow or Realtor.com, giving his clients a head start. Plus, he knows which areas offer the best:

• Sunset views

• Privacy buffers

• Swimming conditions

• Rental ROI potential

Frequently Asked Questions

Q. What types of homes are available on Spider Lake?

A. You'll find everything from cozy 2-bedroom cabins and rustic cottages to expansive lakefront homes and newly constructed modern builds.

Q. Is Spider Lake good for year-round living?

A. Yes! Many residents live here full time and enjoy all four seasons—from summer boating to winter snowmobiling.

Q. Are there boat restrictions on Spider Lake?

A. The lake allows motorized and non-motorized boats. However, certain areas are designated as no-wake zones for safety and conservation.

Q. How far is Spider Lake from Traverse City?

A. Roughly 10–12 miles or about a 20-minute drive—close enough for convenience, far enough for tranquility.

Q. Can I use a Spider Lake property as a short-term rental?

A. Yes. Many properties are vacation rentals, and there’s strong seasonal demand. Be sure to check local township regulations and apply for required permits.

Q. What should I look for in a waterfront home inspection?

A. Key items include dock stability, shoreline erosion, septic system condition, and flood insurance needs. A waterfront-specific inspector is recommended.

Conclusion: Find Your Perfect Slice of Northern Michigan

Ready to Make Spider Lake Home?

Whether you're searching for a personal paradise, seasonal escape, or a smart investment, Spider Lake delivers. From tranquil views to vibrant community charm, it’s one of Traverse City’s best-kept secrets.

Contact BrookWalsh.com for Personalized Assistance

Your dream home might be just a click away. Work with a local who knows the market inside and out. contact Brook Walsh or reach out today to schedule a showing or virtual tour.

Discover More at NorthernMichiganEscapes.com

Want help renting out your new property? Northern Michigan Escapes is your go-to partner for vacation rental success—offering property management, marketing, and concierge services tailored to Northern Michigan homes.

Continue Your Northern Michigan Real Estate Search. Explore homes and real estate in the Northern Michigan communities below or contact Brook Walsh to help you with your search.